If a mechanic replaced a part on a car, and it malfunctioned or wasn't the right part, are they liable to cover any damages caused by their faulty work? Details below.


Asked by Jan 15, 2015 at 12:16 AM about the 2005 GMC Yukon XL

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

A coworker of mine, her car when she
bought it, had issue with leaking
transmission fluid. The shop(of the
dealership) put thin rubber hoses to replace
the transmission line(removing the metal
ones that had rusted through), the hoses
hardly lasted a few months before leaking
started and then one day, they ultimately
shredded and fell off causing her
transmission fluid to completely drain from
her car. She got her line replaced again by a
different shop and the mechanic said that it
wasn't the correct hose and he was baffled
that they would put that on there. Within a
couple of weeks, no leaking, but her first 2
gears seem to not be working so she
hasn't been driving. The second mechanic
told her that she might have issues with her
transmission after the rubber hoses came
off. Was the first shop in the right for
putting the rubber hoses on her car? And
are they liable for her transmission failing?

6 Answers


Was it a licenced shop


Yes,if they were whom the dealer refered her to. So is the dealer. Lemon Law! The ? Is how much time has lapsed?


The dealer did refer her to the shop, and because it's an actual business I would assume that they are licensed.


All depends on how much time has gone between now and then.If she has documentation to support the two repairs etc.


You say it is old enough and has enough miles that the steel tubes rusted through. Then the dealer had you go to another shop besides them. That shop found the issue and used hose instead of steeline that ends in hose. Then you had issues with lower ranges in the trans. You think the fluid loss caused internal damage. But there is much paperwork to be weeded through. so many questions to answer. You can have the diagnosing entity call the dealer and find out how they can get it corrected, or get your papers ready for court. The people who were paid to correct it may have to be consulted in your state. You keep going where you get them to listen and take notes as to who you speak to and all that. Ask the sales person, his boss, up the line till you have your answer. if they cannot get it covered, or corrected, you need legal advice for the laws in your state. Bring your paper that says who bought what from whom for how much, and what was your coverage. You are appealing to the ones the paper suggests you goto.


Have your copy of the work performed. have the same of the new diagnosis the hoses failed, have the names and phone numbers as you go. They may want to speak to the diagnoser of the gear range loss. and the repairing shop. Then the cost and coverage is with the dealer, and the questioned repair shop.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

Yukon XL

Looking for a Used Yukon XL in your area?

CarGurus has 6,726 nationwide Yukon XL listings starting at $2,495.


Search GMC Yukon XL Questions

GMC Yukon XL Experts

#1 TK76
Reputation 270
#2 FordNut
Reputation 220
#3 kbro
Reputation 170
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used Chevrolet Suburban"
667 Great Deals out of 24,294 listings starting at $2,000
Used GMC Yukon XL Denali"
200 Great Deals out of 7,542 listings starting at $3,984
Used GMC Yukon"
568 Great Deals out of 14,716 listings starting at $1,500
Used GMC Yukon Denali"
33 Great Deals out of 4,640 listings starting at $7,995
Used Chevrolet Tahoe"
1,124 Great Deals out of 36,607 listings starting at $1,695
Used Cadillac Escalade ESV"
178 Great Deals out of 6,164 listings starting at $2,499
Used Ford Expedition"
582 Great Deals out of 21,462 listings starting at $2,111
Used GMC Sierra 2500HD"
165 Great Deals out of 15,337 listings starting at $1,900
Used Cadillac Escalade"
392 Great Deals out of 11,254 listings starting at $2,999
Used GMC Sierra 1500"
1,054 Great Deals out of 56,401 listings starting at $2,400
Used Lincoln Navigator"
149 Great Deals out of 6,090 listings starting at $1,999
Used Toyota Sequoia"
168 Great Deals out of 6,743 listings starting at $2,977
Used Chevrolet Silverado 1500"
2,457 Great Deals out of 144,284 listings starting at $1,995
Used Nissan Armada"
166 Great Deals out of 6,383 listings starting at $3,900

Used Cars For Sale

2017 GMC Yukon XL For Sale
239 listings starting at $50,504
2016 GMC Yukon XL For Sale
29 Great Deals out of 3,052 listings starting at $42,940
2015 GMC Yukon XL For Sale
23 Great Deals out of 542 listings starting at $32,066
2014 GMC Yukon XL For Sale
9 Great Deals out of 141 listings starting at $22,995
2013 GMC Yukon XL For Sale
25 Great Deals out of 275 listings starting at $16,500