Used Subaru Legacy in New York, NY

New Search

Filter Results

listings

Price

- Loading...

Mileage

- Loading...

Accidents Reported

Text Search

Price Drops

Add Similar Cars

CarGurus Quick Poll

Looking for a New Subaru Legacy?

5,363 new Subaru Legacy listings
2001 Subaru Legacy L Review
by Michael

Why I love this car.

I love my car because it is to me a perfect blend of performance and reliability. Build quality is very strong and durable. Gas milieage could be better but not bad. Fun to drive? HELL YEAH! I LOVE MY SUBARU!

Loading...
Featured Listings
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/07/30/22/43/2012_subaru_legacy-pic-7750625152965195856-152x114.jpeg

2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Hillside, NJ 07205

Great Deal
$2,790 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $17,690

Price: $14,900

Mileage: 37,951

Location: Hillside, NJ 07205

Average time on market: 41 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Ruby Red Pearl Description: Used 2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $14,900, 37,951 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (12 reviews) "They responded with bad information. I emailed then confirmed by telephone that the Toyota Rav4 was still available because I didn't want to make the trip if it wasn't. I was assured that it was and would be held until I reached the dealership that afternoon. When we arrived the Sales manager Newman told me that Rav4 was sold yesterday. ..also they proclaim no hidden fees with their "no hassle no hidden fees" but charge a documentation fee of $399 another lie"
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/08/19/23/34/2011_subaru_legacy-pic-2609573649096532648-152x114.jpeg

2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Long Island City, NY 11101

Great Deal
$2,402 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $18,892

Price: $16,490

Mileage: 13,325

Location: Long Island City, NY 11101

Average time on market: 41 days Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Black Description: Used 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $16,490, 13,325 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (2 reviews) "got back to me super fast!"
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/08/12/13/12/2011_subaru_legacy-pic-6561991272689137176-152x114.jpeg

2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Hicksville, NY 11801

Great Deal
$1,511 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $17,606

Price: $16,095

Mileage: 36,702

Location: Hicksville, NY 11801

Average time on market: 41 days Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Blue Description: Used 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $16,095, 36,702 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (9 reviews) "They responded to inquiry and followed up. I bought locally "
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/06/05/21/07/2010_subaru_legacy-pic-4538029331346669116-152x114.jpeg

2010 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Premium Used Cars in Shrewsbury, NJ 07702

Great Deal
$2,621 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $18,920

Price: $16,299

Mileage: 46,306

Location: Shrewsbury, NJ 07702

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Azurite Blue Pearl Description: Used 2010 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Premium for sale - $16,299, 46,306 miles with Sunroof/Moonroof, Ambient Light Package, Light Package
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/08/09/11/30/2012_subaru_legacy-pic-1032479017931732659-152x114.jpeg

2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Westbury, NY 11590

Great Deal
$1,558 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $18,556

Price: $16,998

Mileage: 27,097

Location: Westbury, NY 11590

Average time on market: 41 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Gray Description: Used 2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $16,998, 27,097 miles with Aluminum Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (1 review) "The worst experience of my life I traded my Mercedes E350 I was offered a set price by niko and when Gerry took over my application he low balled. Me please ladies and gentlemen be cautious buyer be cautions when buying from them they are terrible the worst customer service they don't return calls I am not a bitter customer I'm just an honest buyer who got the worst end of the deal. Thank you Redigo"
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/08/19/04/16/2004_subaru_legacy-pic-4235682875528062111-152x114.jpeg

2004 Subaru Legacy L 35th Anniversary Edition Used Cars in Edison, NJ 08817

Good Deal
$1,512 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $7,260

Price: $5,748

Mileage: 91,730

Location: Edison, NJ 08817

Average time on market: 24 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 4-Speed Automatic Color: Silver Stone Metallic Description: Used 2004 Subaru Legacy L 35th Anniversary Edition for sale - $5,748, 91,730 miles with Sunroof/Moonroof, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (22 reviews) "Dealer never returned my phone call so I emailed through the website. Emailed me back and stated they couldn't reach me by phone, but they never tried. Still playing phone tag as they won't call me when I tell them I'm available."
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/08/30/14/05/2013_subaru_legacy-pic-6718681821433638645-152x114.jpeg

2013 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited Used Cars in Hicksville, NY 11801

Good Deal
$2,222 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $26,217

Price: $23,995

Mileage: 14,862

Location: Hicksville, NY 11801

Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: 5-Speed Automatic Color: Silver Description: Used 2013 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited for sale - $23,995, 14,862 miles with Bluetooth, Navigation System, Sunroof/Moonroof
Avg. Dealer Rating: (9 reviews) "Very good experience overall Would recommend this dealer"
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/07/03/13/43/2005_subaru_legacy-pic-4945462497483972237-152x114.jpeg

2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5 GT Limited Used Cars in Hillside, NJ 07205

Good Deal
$2,171 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $9,166

Price: $6,995

Mileage: 125,100

Location: Hillside, NJ 07205

Average time on market: 18 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Silver Description: Used 2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5 GT Limited for sale - $6,995, 125,100 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (2 reviews) "I wanted to share my personal experience with Exclusive Auto Group, located at 126 Route 22 East Hillside, NJ. 07205.126 Route 22 East On June 12th, 2013 I called to inquire about a vehicle they had on cars.com and advertised at $42,995. I spoke with Carlos who was very friendly and told me it was still available but was in the body shop to have a kit put on it. This did not deter my interest because the kit they were placing on the car was one I was interested in anyway and just an added bonus. After talking with him and a few phone calls I agreed with him and his boss was also involved to pay full asking for the vehicle. Carlos assured it would be ready by mid the following week and asked that I put a $5000.00 deposit down to secure which I gladly did. In the days to come photos came in of the body kit being put on and communication from Carlos was good and I felt good about the purchase. Like any used car buyer should do I hired a 3rd party mechanic who specializes in this vehicle to go do a check on it to ensure it was mechanically sound ($150.00). In addition I booked a flight from Greensboro to NJ ($224.30) for Thursday 27th, 2013. The Mechanic came back and I was willing to accept the condition of the vehicle but simply asked Carlos to look at one item, which he did and said was taken care of. Thursday morning came after receiving more photos of the hard work they put into the car the night before and I was packed and ready to head out the door when I get a call from Carlos (7:00 am). Carlos explains to me that his boss called him and instructed him that he could not sell the car for the $42,995 as agreed and advertised. He said the paint and body work was simply too much and that they needed to get more for the vehicle. Carlos stated they would take no less than $48,000, and knowing I wanted an extended warranty he would cover half of the ($5000.00) warranty and sell me the car and the warranty for $50,000. I was highly disappointed needless to say and in the end we just could not close the deal. Carlos said he would refund my deposit, fully cover my $224.30 flight and the $150.00 spent on the mechanic which would just in the end put me out for my time spent. I immediately faxed him the bills so he could use them for the reimbursements as requested. A few days later I checked my card and indeed the $5000.00 deposit was reimbursed, however several calls and text later initiated by me and I still have not seen the $374.30 in other expenses promised and were just past 4 weeks later. Carlos in out last communications said he has sent the $150.00 for the mechanic, but is not responsible for the flight (contradiction to his statements before). He seemed to think Expedia or the airline would credit or refund this money but after calling both companies this is clearly not the case. For me the overall experience was not pleasant and I would never do business with them again. "
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/08/09/01/04/2004_subaru_legacy_l_35th_anniversary_edition-pic-2882138102649255291-152x114.jpeg

2004 Subaru Legacy L 35th Anniversary Edition Used Cars in Staten Island, NY 10314

Good Deal
$1,423 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $6,018

Price: $4,595

Mileage: 128,009

Location: Staten Island, NY 10314

Average time on market: 24 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 4-Speed Automatic Color: Silver Description: Used 2004 Subaru Legacy L 35th Anniversary Edition for sale - $4,595, 128,009 miles with Sunroof/Moonroof, Alloy Wheels
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/08/15/06/36/2008_subaru_legacy-pic-9223133544084199648-152x114.jpeg

2008 Subaru Legacy 2.5 i Limited Used Cars in Freehold, NJ 07728-2680

Good Deal
$1,929 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $10,829

Price: $8,900

Mileage: 103,795

Location: Freehold, NJ 07728-2680

Average time on market: 19 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 4-Speed Automatic Color: Obsidian Black Pearl Description: Used 2008 Subaru Legacy 2.5 i Limited for sale - $8,900, 103,795 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (6 reviews) "Excellent service"
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/06/27/08/34/2011_subaru_legacy-pic-3805665505114377297-152x114.jpeg

2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Used Cars in Bridgewater, NJ 08807

Good Deal
$1,257 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $17,257

Price: $16,000

Mileage: 18,409

Location: Bridgewater, NJ 08807

Average time on market: 35 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Black Description: Used 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i for sale - $16,000, 18,409 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (5 reviews) "I've had nothing but problems with the vehicle that I bought from them. So far it has been a new belt, rear brake rotors, a check engine light for a catalytic converter, and the rear gate not opening. When I called the dealership I was told that the car was sold as is."
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/05/28/04/21/2009_subaru_legacy-pic-4354186403624778596-152x114.jpeg

2009 Subaru Legacy 2.5 i Special Edition Used Cars in Huntington Station, NY 11746

Good Deal
$1,218 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $11,718

Price: $10,500

Mileage: 80,550

Location: Huntington Station, NY 11746

Average time on market: 21 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Deep Bronze Metallic Description: Used 2009 Subaru Legacy 2.5 i Special Edition for sale - $10,500, 80,550 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (7 reviews) "good"
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/07/08/08/52/2004_subaru_legacy-pic-1711110971760623200-152x114.jpeg

2004 Subaru Legacy L 35th Anniversary Edition Used Cars in Huntington, NY 11743

Good Deal
$1,281 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $6,176

Price: $4,895

Mileage: 125,000

Location: Huntington, NY 11743

Average time on market: 24 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Silver Stone Metallic Description: Used 2004 Subaru Legacy L 35th Anniversary Edition for sale - $4,895, 125,000 miles
http://images.cobaltgroup.com/5/5/8/9275786855x152.jpg

2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited Used Cars in White Plains, NY 10607

Good Deal
$1,545 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $22,215

Price: $20,670

Mileage: 8,376

Location: White Plains, NY 10607

Average time on market: 33 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Ice Silver Metallic Description: Used 2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited for sale - $20,670, 8,376 miles with Sunroof/Moonroof, Alloy Wheels
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/08/20/10/54/2011_subaru_legacy-pic-7517859279464228545-152x114.jpeg

2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Long Island City, NY 11101

Good Deal
$1,119 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $16,608

Price: $15,489

Mileage: 53,295

Location: Long Island City, NY 11101

Average time on market: 41 days Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Silver Description: Used 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $15,489, 53,295 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (2 reviews) "Did not visit. Their car prices were consistently higher than the competition. Did not see anything worthy of the trip to Long Island City."
Please wait ...
All Listings
Please wait ...
Featured Listing
First Previous
Page # of #
Next
You will receive listing updates from CarGurus.com when new listings match your search. Privacy Policy.

Filter your search criteria!

A large number of listings matched your criteria. You are seeing the top listings.

Used Subaru Legacy By Year

Vehicle Deals Starting Price Total Available
2014 Subaru Legacy 9 Great Deals $17,999 519 listings
2013 Subaru Legacy 27 Great Deals $13,995 684 listings
2012 Subaru Legacy 28 Great Deals $11,595 608 listings
2011 Subaru Legacy 40 Great Deals $9,995 1,090 listings
2010 Subaru Legacy 11 Great Deals $7,300 282 listings
2009 Subaru Legacy 5 Great Deals $6,200 185 listings
2008 Subaru Legacy 14 Great Deals $4,995 221 listings

Similar Cars

Subaru Impreza
180 Great Deals out of 9,256 listings starting at $1,800
Subaru Outback
298 Great Deals out of 14,517 listings starting at $1,499
Subaru Forester
234 Great Deals out of 23,924 listings starting at $1,895

New Subaru Legacy By Year

2015 Subaru Legacy
5,093 listings
2014 Subaru Legacy
519 listings

Used Subaru Legacy By City

Subaru Legacy in Stamford CT
9 Great Deals out of 891 listings starting at $2,999
Subaru Legacy in Allentown PA
11 Great Deals out of 769 listings starting at $1,495
Subaru Legacy in Philadelphia PA
10 Great Deals out of 660 listings starting at $1,495
Subaru Legacy in Hartford CT
9 Great Deals out of 824 listings starting at $2,499
Subaru Legacy in Scranton PA
388 listings starting at $3,495
Subaru Legacy in Springfield MA
12 Great Deals out of 908 listings starting at $2,499
Subaru Legacy in Albany NY
8 Great Deals out of 238 listings starting at $5,995
Subaru Legacy in Providence RI
14 Great Deals out of 852 listings starting at $2,499
Subaru Legacy in Worcester MA
17 Great Deals out of 996 listings starting at $2,499
Subaru Legacy in Harrisburg PA
460 listings starting at $4,433
Subaru Legacy in Baltimore MD
457 listings starting at $4,900
Subaru Legacy in Boston MA
13 Great Deals out of 733 listings starting at $2,499
Subaru Legacy in Syracuse NY
4 Great Deals out of 163 listings starting at $5,995
Subaru Legacy in Washington DC
305 listings starting at $4,995
Subaru Legacy in Rochester NY
201 listings starting at $1,195