Found a basket case 58 mercury 2 door monterey is it worth doing anything with? Is it worth parting out the chrome parts?


Asked by Jul 31, 2012 at 08:34 PM about the 1958 Mercury Monterey

Question type: General

All parts seem to be there, crhome is good but some pitted. All emblems look complete and solid.  interior is shot from mice.  motor is like a solid iron anchor.   I have a few more pics.  It has a V8 from what I can tell.  Hard to look at as it was covered in leaves and pine needles.  Anything worth pulling off the car?  I hate to see an oldie like this go to the crusher!

3 Answers


Well, there are a few questions... which engine,360 or 400 hp. Merc-o-matic transmission or standard with overdrive; and what about A/C? With these questions answered, you can see what the restored value would be. If you got it running to average condition, it could bring up to $7500. I have not seen any of these go for over $20k in absolute show condition! I see a car in the woods that seems to be resting on the floor pan. RUST! maybe most of it. Is the engine frozen... big bucks and then you get to the tranny. Unless you are a full blown body man, and can do most of the labor yourself, I don't see how you get this up and running for less that $7000-$8000. You will have to decide it it is worth the time and money. I am not even sure if you could make any money just parting it out since you didn't say how much you have to pay for it.. Personnel I would pass on it. Good luck. '

Adam Utz

Absolutely , There are NOT that many 57-58 Mercury's around I have a 58 2dr hardtop and a 4 dr wagon , actually its probably a 383 , if your lucky it could be a 430. where are you located at . Also if the doors are decent they can be at least 200-300 for the pair.send me a picture of the engine if you have one and I'll be able to tell you what it is


When I go after an old car it's because I like it. I'm not looking for an investment. I think the car is cool so I buy it & fix it. If it costs more to fix than "book value" who cares? I have a car that I like & enjoy. If you like it, I say go for it. -Jim

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

Looking for a Used Monterey in your area?
CarGurus has 177 nationwide Monterey listings starting at $3,150.

Search Mercury Monterey Questions

Mercury Monterey Experts

#1 gws
Reputation 110
#2 kbro
Reputation 70
#3 joemom
Reputation 40
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used Cars For Sale

2007 Mercury Monterey For Sale
7 listings starting at $4,995
2006 Mercury Monterey For Sale
14 listings starting at $3,950
2005 Mercury Monterey For Sale
35 listings starting at $3,150