2012 Porsche 911 Review

911

Looking for a Used 911 in your area?

CarGurus has 3,357 nationwide 911 listings starting at $12,000.

ZIP:

Not sure what you want?

Find the models that are right for you using the CarGurus Car Finder.

Zip:

Trims

Carrera
Avg. Price: $77,560
Carrera 4 AWD
Avg. Price: $78,449
Carrera 4 AWD Cabriolet
2 national listings
Avg. Price: $81,873
Carrera 4S AWD
Avg. Price: $83,022
Carrera 4S AWD Cabriolet
Avg. Price: $91,500
Carrera Cabriolet
Avg. Price: $79,541
Carrera GTS
Avg. Price: $86,502
Carrera GTS Cabriolet
11 national listings
Avg. Price: $89,138
Carrera S
Avg. Price: $86,749
Carrera S Cabriolet
Avg. Price: $93,862
GT3
Show 7 more trims

Porsche 911 Experts

#1 Tom Demyan
Tom Demyan
Reputation 170
#2 Smitty22
Smitty22
Reputation 100
#2 Michael Kane
Michael Kane
Reputation 100
View All

Average User Score

55 stars

Based on 1 review

Should I, Or Shouldn't I? by breem
 — That was the question. I’ve had on lease a 2009 Cayman, which at the time I made that deal, found myself quite stunned to be sitting there at the local Dealership putting pen to the dotted line. I was... Read More

2012 Porsche 911 Overview

Overall User Score

5 out of 5 stars5 out of 5 stars5 out of 5 stars5 out of 5 stars5 out of 5 stars55

Based on 1 review

2012 Porsche 911

Porsche swears its new 911 really is new. New engines, new bodywork, new interior – Porsche claims the only pieces that carry over from the old 911 include the piston, crank, steering wheel and a smattering of parts from the PDK transmission. Whether a company should be praised or criticized for changing so much while changing so very little will be left up to consumers. With a longer wheelbase and wider track, engines boasting more power *and* more efficiency and a substantially improved interior, all we can say is this “new” 911 is certainly better.

That is, unless you actually like all the things that make a 911 special. That flat-6 hanging out over the rear axle hasn’t been air-cooled in over a decade, and there’s little worry anymore that you’ll get sent spinning into the next corner thanks to maniacal oversteer. Yes, these are both good things, but let’s not forget that quirks breed character. After all, would anyone buy an old British sports car if Lucas wasn’t threatening to run out on you at the mere hint of rain?

Okay, bad example. The 911 is better, even if only trained eyes can tell it apart from the car it replaces. And that will be made easier this year, as only base Carrera and Carrera S trims get the changeover, with Carrera 4, Targa and GTS trims remaining unchanged, meaning you can actually compare the two side by side.

For the new model, 4 inches were added to the wheelbase and 2 inches to the track. On the outside you’ll notice LEDs in front and back and a new front fascia with a wider grille. That’s nice, but German automobiles aren’t known for styling, they’re known for engineering. So what do the Stuggart stooges have in store for the new 911?

Let’s start with the big news. An industry first, the new 911 comes with a 7-speed manual transmission to complement the venerable 7-speed PDK automated manual option. This leads a long list of new mechanical features, including a new active chassis control system (PDCC), a new torque-vectoring system (PTV) and sadly, electro-mechanical power steering. While the PDCC and PTV systems only enhance the 911's already staggering handling, the electro-mechanical steering is a disappointment, providing all the vague numbness we’ve come to expect from such setups. There’s no doubt things will only improve, but they aren’t there yet.

Thankfully, there are only good things to say about the two new engines. The Carrera starts with a direct-injected 3.4-liter “boxer” 6 that delivers 350 hp and 287 lb-ft of torque. While this is a loss of 0.2 liters from the engine it replaces, it delivers 5 extra hp, and with a lighter weight and new 7-speed transmission, Porsche says it’ll be more efficient as well. Tests have put it at under 4.5 seconds to get to 60 mph, and that’s proof enough of its competence.

The Carrera S gets a frightening 400 horses from a 3.8-liter boxer 6 – an addition of 15 hp. Torque drops a bit to 295, but again Porsche assures us this upgraded 3.8 will yield increased efficiency, decreased emissions and faster 0-60 times – currently estimated around 4 seconds even with the revamped PDK transmission.

But you’re a driver, and you want to shift with your feet, right? Well, despite the extra room thanks to the wheels being shoved further to the corners, there’s not a lot of space in the footwell. It’s cramped enough to make operation of those three pedals difficult and awkward, as the whole setup is angled toward the center of the car. It’s a shame, and it really makes the PDK the preferred choice here.

Footwell complaints aside, the interior received a lot of attention—and apparently a lot of inspiration from its 4-door brother, the Panamera. For a lot of Porsche faithful, this is a sacrilegious source from which to draw insight, but the improvement is hard to argue. Yes, a larger backseat is against the 911's heritage, but it sure is useful. Don’t worry though, it’s still too small for a real-life adult to use, so perhaps a bit of a nod to history there. Legroom gets an extra inch up front, but it’s hard to notice. While quality, fit and finish of this new design are beyond reproach, testers have commented that the new layout feels more cramped than before. While this is good for things like bringing the gearshift closer to the driver, it’s not so great for long-distance comfort. After all, most 911s never see the track.

So this year you get your choice of 911 – new or old. There’s no question the improvements made to this icon do indeed improve, with the exception of the electro-mechanical steering. Even that provides all the precision of the old hydraulic system, it’s just the feel that’s missing. And that speaks to everything the 911 has become – flawless precision with a tarnished soul. You can have your double-clutch transmissions and torque-vectoring, but I’ll take the looming threat of air-cooled death around the next corner any day.

Updated

A CarGurus contributor since 2008, Michael started his career writing about cars with the SCCA - winning awards during his time as editor of Top End magazine. Since then, his journalistic travels have taken him from NY to Boston to CA, completing a cross-country tour on a restored vintage Suzuki. While his preference is for fine German automobiles - and the extra leg room they so often afford - his first automobile memories center around impromptu Mustang vs. Corvette races down the local highway, in the backseat of his father's latest acquisition.

What's your take on the 2012 Porsche 911?

People researching a 2012 Porsche 911 contacted a dealer about

2012 Porsche 911, Exterior View, manufacturer, exterior
Porsche 911
76% of the time
Chevrolet Corvette
7% of the time
Porsche Boxster
5% of the time
Porsche Cayman
5% of the time
911
Looking for a Used 911 in your area?
CarGurus has 3,357 nationwide 911 listings starting at $12,000.
ZIP:

Porsche 911 Questions

ca1surf
0

How Is Residual Value Calculated On A Lease

When I'm in the finance office deciding on a lease verses purchase how do they calculate the residual value of a cars worth in 3 years

222 views with 1 answer (last answer about a year ago)
Bruno Prata
5

I Am Taking My Driving License For The First Time In My Life. Where Can I B...

76 views with 1 answer (last answer 2 years ago)