2010 Subaru Legacy Review


Looking for a Used Legacy in your area?

CarGurus has 8,690 nationwide Legacy listings starting at $1,700.


Not sure what you want?

Find the models that are right for you using the CarGurus Car Finder.



2.5GT Limited
8 national listings
Avg. Price: $19,079
2.5GT Premium
Avg. Price: $18,757
Avg. Price: $13,255
2.5i Limited
Avg. Price: $15,752
2.5i Premium
Avg. Price: $14,091
3.6R Limited
Avg. Price: $18,109
3.6R Premium
Avg. Price: $16,969

Subaru Legacy Experts

#1 Nick Eidemiller
Nick Eidemiller
Reputation 530
#2 dandyoun
Reputation 320
#3 Tom Hawkins
Tom Hawkins
Reputation 270
View All

Average User Score

4.85 stars

Based on 18 reviews

Luxury/sport Comfort In A Nicer Package, But Still A Subaru At Heart, Which Is Why I Bought It by LASubaruFan
 — This is the new Subaru! In some ways, for this 5x previous Subie owner and a big fan of the brand, it is a bit of an adjustment in that it feels bigger, more luxurious, softer...but that said, under a... Read More
Love At First Sight Since Day One. Still Love Every Second Of Driving It. by Ali
 — I bought this car with 40k miles back in 2013. The Lariche Subaru in Findley Ohio had service this car from headlights to exhaust muffler. Just regular oil change and tire rotation on this car until i... Read More
My Baby by Jonathan
 — I love the Legacy for the 256 horsepower 3.6 litre flat six and 5 speed SPORTSHIFT automatic transmission that provides spirited performance for a nearly 3600 pound car. The car as can be expected f... Read More

2010 Subaru Legacy Review

The Good

Class-leading fuel economy and interior space coupled with some potent engines and a comfortable ride only bolster the 2010 Subaru Legacy’s already strong foundation in its class.

The Bad

The non-turbo 2.5 is slightly underpowered, but it’s the sloppy six-speed manual that really disappoints in the 2010 Legacy.

The CarGurus View

It’s because the Legacy does so many things right that the poor performance of its six-speed manual transmission is such a disappointment. The 2.5GT was always an odd duck in the trim lineup, but beloved, and with the six-speed being the only option for that trim, it leaves it dead in the water. Non-turbo versions are sluggish, but not painfully, so if you don’t need the speed of the 3.6R trims, the 2.5is may be your best bet.

At a Glance

A twenty-year lifespan provides a lot of time for refinement, and Subaru had a heck of a fine starting point with the Legacy. Before the official unveiling at the New York International Auto Show (April 10th-19th), Subaru revealed specs and pics for the 2010 Legacy, showing us a car that's bigger, taller, and more powerful.

The new Legacy has been redesigned and is almost 3 inches larger all around, including the wheelbase, stretching its midsize limits slightly. This all-wheel-drive (AWD) four-door sedan additionally gets some new trim levels and a new top-tier six-cylinder engine, as well as modifications to its four-cylinder choices, improving power and economy. Even with more changes and additions inside as well, the price for the base 2.5i starts at just under $20,000, $800 less than in 2009.


2010 Subaru Legacy

2.5i trims are powered by a 2.5-liter boxer-four producing 170 hp and 170 lb-ft of torque that comes in at 4,000 rpm as opposed to 4,400 rpm in 2009, thanks to a resin-based intake manifold that lowers weight. Improved cooling and exhaust tuning has also increased fuel economy, bumping the six-speed manual transmission to 19/27 mpg, while the CVT option for this engine achieves a class-leading 23/31 on regular-grade gasoline, and is the first longitudinally mounted CVT in an AWD car.

The 2.5GT gets a turbocharged version of the 2.5-liter engine, with increased power and efficiency over last year. Numbers show at 265 hp and 258 lb-ft of torque, an increase of 22 hp and 17 lb-ft of torque over last year's, but even more impressive is that those numbers show up at 5,600 and 2,000 rpm, respectively, as opposed to 6,000 and 3,600 for 2009. This means a 0-60 sprint of 5.9 seconds – 2 seconds faster than last year! And all of this due to a modified turbocharger that also increases efficiency to 18/25 with the six-speed manual, the only transmission available for the engine, although premium-grade gasoline is required.

The real performer is the 3.6-liter boxer six in the 3.6R trims. With another increase of 11 hp and 32 lb-ft of torque, the turbocharged six puts out 256 hp and 247 lb-ft of torque, drops its peak hp rpm to 6000, and achieves 18/25 mpg on regular-grade gasoline, even with the strange choice of the five-speed automatic that is the sole offering.

Ride & Handling

2010 Subaru Legacy

The Legacy's MacPherson front struts and double wishbone rear suspension have been revised this year in a configuration that is now being used in all Subarus. With steering response that has been described as slightly overboosted, the Legacy is not known for handling like a slot car, but it is more than capable, especially with the lauded Subaru AWD system. Still, don’t be surprised by body lean if you push it too hard in the corners, as comfort seems to be the primary concern here. As such, the 16-inch wheels on the 2.5i, and the 17-inch units on the premium 2.5 and 3.6 trims absorb all but the most aggressive bumps with poise, and even the 18-inch 2.5GT wheels measure up quite well. Subaru is also boasting a 20% increase in braking response and power, thanks to a revised booster. It’s a welcome upgrade, even though the previous Legacy didn’t exactly suffer from poor braking.

Cabin & Comfort

2010 Subaru Legacy

Due to the Legacy’s growth for 2010, rear passengers enjoy an additional 3.9 inches of legroom, as well as a substantially larger door opening. A 3.3-inch height increase means additional headroom front and rear for overall interior space that is well above the class average. Even those over 6 feet tall will have no issue with either leg or head space, even with the optional sunroof.

Controls are well placed, and the main gauges are easy to read, although some have complained about the information panel being too small for quick glances. Interior materials are well-fitted, but are substantially made up of the hard plastics that are usual for the class. Still, the Legacy manages to avoid looking cheap, even in its entry-level trims.

Subaru attempted to create a more open space, eliminating the lever-operated parking brake in favor of a cleaner electronic option, and redesigning the instrument panel along the same lines. The three-spoke steering wheel has been redesigned and includes audio controls and paddle shifters for automatic trims. Interior storage has also been increased with a larger console box and armrest.


2010 Subaru Legacy

With six standard airbags, four-wheel antilock disc brakes with a stronger boost system, anti-skid and front seat active head restraints, the Legacy has managed to earn a 5-star rating in all NHTSA test categories, a substantial achievement.

What Owners Think

The Legacy's increases in both fuel economy and interior room have received much deserved universal praise, but a painfully vague six-speed manual transmission frustrates many owners, especially considering it's the only option for the otherwise excellent 2.5GT trim.


A CarGurus contributor since 2008, Michael started his career writing about cars with the SCCA - winning awards during his time as editor of Top End magazine. Since then, his journalistic travels have taken him from NY to Boston to CA, completing a cross-country tour on a restored vintage Suzuki. While his preference is for fine German automobiles - and the extra leg room they so often afford - his first automobile memories center around impromptu Mustang vs. Corvette races down the local highway, in the backseat of his father's latest acquisition.

What's your take on the 2010 Subaru Legacy?

People researching a 2010 Subaru Legacy contacted a dealer about

2010 Subaru Legacy, Front Left Quarter View, exterior, manufacturer
Subaru Legacy
41% of the time
Subaru Outback
9% of the time
Toyota RAV4
6% of the time
Chrysler 300
6% of the time
Looking for a Used Legacy in your area?
CarGurus has 8,690 nationwide Legacy listings starting at $1,700.

Subaru Legacy Questions

Corey Blackledge

Can I Upgrade My 2010 Subaru Premium Package To The Gt (clone)?

I have a 2.5i 2010 Legacy , and was wondering if I can attach the turbo and the hood from a GT to clone it? Just looking for the upgrades that make sense and will not cost me a new motor in the long...

16 views with 1 answer (last answer about a month ago)

How To Replace Headlight Bulb On '10 Subaru Legacy?

736 views with 1 answer (last answer 2 years ago)

Customizing A Legacy

Just curious as to customizing a 2010 Legacy. Don't know where to start.

42 views with 3 answers (last answer 11 months ago)

2010 Subaru Legacy Heater Problem

I have a 2010 Subaru Legacy Sedan. It has an amazing heater, except for the setting that should blow heat to your feet. With that selected, your feet still freeze in the winter. Has anyone else had ...

13 views with no answers yet
Nicole Sahaj-Myers

Should A Cvt Transmission Fail At 92,000 Miles On An Automatic? Is This A D...

11 views with 1 answer (last answer about a week ago)