2010 Mercury Mariner Review

Mariner

Looking for a Used Mariner in your area?

CarGurus has 1,908 nationwide Mariner listings starting at $2,500.

ZIP:

Not sure what you want?

Find the models that are right for you using the CarGurus Car Finder.

Zip:

Trims

Base
Avg. Price: $14,079
Base 4WD
Avg. Price: $14,768
Premier
Avg. Price: $14,676
Premier 4WD
Avg. Price: $15,930

Mercury Mariner Experts

#1 2022erik
2022erik
Reputation 140
#2 kbro
kbro
Reputation 50
#2 Tom Demyan
Tom Demyan
Reputation 50
View All

Average User Score

45 stars

Based on 2 reviews

Really Good Smaller Family Hauler. by wilscaal
 — Appearance, power, feature value for the price was excellent. Comfortable ride and generally met all our needs. It was more sporty then luxury. Everything worked very well. What was really nice was u... Read More
Comfortable And Practical Suv by DriftJunkie22
 — This SUV is great quality and gets great MPG. It is a great luxury ride without the insane luxury price. Nothing has broken on it yet but I anticipate fairly low repair costs as it is a Ford Escape es... Read More

2010 Mercury Mariner Review

The Good

Actual V6 power and a six-speed automatic were exactly what the Mercury Mariner needed, and together with all-wheel drive and the vehicle's expansive room, make 2010 a great year to grab one.

The Bad

Its four-cylinder engine is slightly underpowered and seriously unrefined, and when coupled with its lackluster interior, the '10 Mariner lacks the chops to back up its pretensions.

The CarGurus View

The extra money you'll spend to get a 2010 Mercury Mariner over a Ford Escape or Mazda Tribute simply isn’t worth it, especially considering the chassis is a design coming up on 10 years old. If you must get one, go with the V6, and perhaps even the all-wheel drive, depending on your climate. Still, it might be best to wait for the next redesign and see if Mercury sorts enough of the problems out to make the Mariner's higher price worth it.

At a Glance

The Mercury Mariner was introduced in 2005 as an upscale sibling to the Mazda Tribute and Ford Escape. The chassis of the Mariner, shared by all three models, has seen duty in the Escape unchanged since 2001. In 2009, the two available engines, a four- and six-cylinder, saw some impressive power and displacement increases, with the four going from a 153-hp 2.3-liter to a 171-hp 2.5 and the 3.0-liter six-cylinder gaining 40 hp for a total of 240. Concurrently, the archaic four-speed automatic was replaced by a six-speed unit, improving fuel efficiency. Available in Base and Premium trims, the Mariner offers front-wheel or all-wheel drive.

Drivetrain

2010 Mercury Mariner

The upgrade to a six-speed automatic transmission was long-awaited, as was the power increase both engines saw in 2009. With that, the base four-cylinder engine grew to a 2.5-liter unit pumping out 171 hp. In front-wheel-drive guise, the four-cylinder has an EPA estimate of 20/28 mpg, a figure that drops to 19/25 with AWD. The engine has adequate power, even for AWD, and a 1,500-pound maximum towing capacity, although it’s intrusively buzzy when laboring and merely annoyingly so at lower rpm.

The 240-hp, 3.0-liter V6 is a sprightly unit, offering ample power and a 3,500-pound maximum towing capacity. EPA estimates put the front-wheel-drive version at 18/26, while AWD trims top out at 17/24, all mated to the six-speed automatic. That transmission has received much praise, both for its smoothness and its quick ability to find the right gear to deliver adequate power in a timely manner.

Ride & Handling

2010 Mercury Mariner

The ride and handling of the 2010 Mercury Mariner are a bit of a mixed bag. While certainly not a disappointment, with controlled lean and roll and impressive impact-absorption, its design is still coming up on a decade old. As such, there’s plenty of room for improvement, especially in regard to highway handling and steering that has been called “cloudy at speed” by owners.

Still, the Mariner surpasses its class standards with regards to overall ride and handling and offers an impressive turning radius of 18.35 feet.

Cabin & Comfort

2010 Mercury Mariner

Again an exercise in contradiction, the Mariner is marketed as a more upscale version of the Escape and Tribute, but fails to live up to those pretensions. The interior’s seemingly sole upgrade is a two-tone layout that is unfortunately made up predominantly of hard, cheap, and sometimes ill-fitting plastics. Many owners and testers alike have found mismatched surfaces and misaligned joints.

That said, the controls themselves are generally well-placed and intuitive, with some minor exceptions. Most issues can be combated by using another of the vehicle’s systems, such as Ford’s Sync voice command system, although one has to consider the fact that you shouldn’t have to bypass or otherwise circumvent your vehicle’s controls just for ease of use.

Space, at least, is abundant for both passengers and cargo, although the rear seats fail to fold flat, curiously. Still, a low deck height and a rear liftgate that also includes opening glass offers convenient storage. Occupants will similarly find a wealth of space, hampered only by the addition of the sunroof.

Safety

2010 Mercury Mariner

Safety options are not lacking in the Mariner, with dual front, front-side, and full curtain-side airbags that benefit from rollover deployment, as well as antilock brakes with anti-skid, a tire-pressure monitor, traction control, electronic stability control, and a brake/shift interlock.

The NHTSA has awarded the Mariner five stars in all tests excepting rollover resistance, in which the Mariner earned three stars.

What Owners Think

Owners were very happy with the upgrades 2009 brought to the Mercury Mariner's drivetrain, however many have been disappointed by the interior materials and finish, especially given the vehicle's price point. However, comfort and performance have not been a weak point of the vehicle and have provided plenty of utility for owners.

Updated

A CarGurus contributor since 2008, Michael started his career writing about cars with the SCCA - winning awards during his time as editor of Top End magazine. Since then, his journalistic travels have taken him from NY to Boston to CA, completing a cross-country tour on a restored vintage Suzuki. While his preference is for fine German automobiles - and the extra leg room they so often afford - his first automobile memories center around impromptu Mustang vs. Corvette races down the local highway, in the backseat of his father's latest acquisition.

What's your take on the 2010 Mercury Mariner?

People researching a 2010 Mercury Mariner contacted a dealer about

2010 Mercury Mariner, Front Left Quarter View, exterior, manufacturer
Mercury Mariner
25% of the time
Ford Escape
15% of the time
Chevrolet TrailBlazer
5% of the time
Jeep Liberty
5% of the time
Mariner
Looking for a Used Mariner in your area?
CarGurus has 1,908 nationwide Mariner listings starting at $2,500.
ZIP:

Mercury Mariner Questions

Jeremy Dawson
0

I'm Searching For A Keyless Code For My 2010 Mercury Mariner Premier. Witho...

7 views with no answers yet
Billy Lovins
0

How To Get The Foglight Unit Out

It has mosture in it

6 views with 1 answer (last answer 4 months ago)
JRohio123
0

2010 Mariner Will Start After Sitting In Sun On Hot Days But None Of The El...

29 views with 3 answers (last answer 4 months ago)
meganellen
0

What Grade Of Gas Should I Use???

25 views with 1 answer (last answer 6 months ago)
Pitt92
0

Transmisson Or Gas Pedal Disconnect

I have a 2010 mercury mariner , several times car acts like the transmission or gas pedal is disconnected. Has happened at various speeds . Any idea what is causing this ?

47 views with 1 answer (last answer about a year ago)