2009 Buick Lucerne Review

Lucerne

Looking for a Used Lucerne in your area?

CarGurus has 3,999 nationwide Lucerne listings starting at $2,987.

ZIP:

Not sure what you want?

Find the models that are right for you using the CarGurus Car Finder.

Zip:

Trims

CX
Avg. Price: $12,877
CXL
Avg. Price: $14,017
CXL Special Edition
Avg. Price: $14,731
Super
Avg. Price: $16,592

Buick Lucerne Experts

#1 seastorm709
seastorm709
Reputation 310
#2 tenspeed
tenspeed
Reputation 280
#3 bwags2
bwags2
Reputation 210
View All

Average User Score

55 stars

Based on 1 review

We Love It by Dave4329
 — This car rides like a living room sofa! We averaged 29 mpg on the first long distance trip and the safety features are exceptional. At 71, eyesight and reflexes aren't as sharp as before, and the bl... Read More

2009 Buick Lucerne Review

The Good

An incredibly smooth and quiet ride provided by Magnetic Ride Control and QuietTuning is matched to a powerful V8 and smooth transmission in the 2009 Buick Lucerne Super to create everything a luxury full-size should be.

The Bad

The base suspension and engine that come in the CX and CXL trims are very simply inadequate in the 2009 Buick Lucerne.

The CarGurus View

The Buick Lucerne is an often overlooked entry in the luxury full-size class. While the CX and CXL trims perhaps deserve this, the Super corrects all their shortcomings, and quite well. While options are available to upgrade both the CX and CXL significantly, it’s the upgraded suspension, steering, and engine of the Super that really make the difference.

At a Glance

With the deletion of the LeSabre and the Park Avenue in 2006, the Lucerne took the lead as Buick’s full-size entry. Riding on a revised version of GM’s G-body platform, utilized previously by the Pontiac Bonneville, the Lucerne has done well since its introduction, representing a full quarter of the full-size sedan sales in the U.S. This four-door, front-wheel-drive vehicle seats up to six passengers in the base CX and midlevel CXL trims, and five in the top-tier Super.

For 2009, the CX and CXL get a host of new standard features, but most significant is the new V6 they both receive, which not only provides 30 additional horsepower, but actually increases gas mileage by 1 mpg in both city and highway driving.

Drivetrain

CX and CXL Lucernes receive a new 3.9-liter, 227-hp V6, which replaces the 197-hp, 3.8-liter V6 of previous model years. In addition to the power increase, the new engine is E85 friendly. Many previous owners complained about a lack of adequate power with the old 3.8, and unfortunately some testers have said the same about the 3.9, despite the power increase. The Super’s 4.6-liter, 292-hp V8, on the other hand, provides ample power for all situations. EPA estimates are 17/26 mpg for the V6 and 15/22 for the V8, for which Buick recommends premium grade fuel.

Both engines are mated to a four-speed automatic transmission, which has been noted to be particularly smooth and responsive with either engine. That said, it should be noted that the V8’s extra power is much more noticeable in the higher end of the RPM range, rather than the lower, making for much better passing and merging at highway speeds. Either engine is quite quiet, as would be expected in this class.

Ride & Handling

2009 Buick Lucerne

No matter what, you can’t expect a sporty ride from the Lucerne. Even the Super, with its upgraded steering and Magnetic Ride Control suspension, is still just capable and never aggressive. The CX and CXL ride a bit sloppily, with a lot of float and wallow, but the Super rides as a full-size luxury sedan should, positives and negatives included, with slightly vague steering that becomes progressively heavier at lower speeds. A very wide turning radius makes parking-lot maneuvers difficult across all trims, but brakes are strong despite a less-than-firm pedal feel.

Cabin & Comfort

2009 Buick Lucerne

As with other aspects, the interior of the Lucerne feels much more appropriate to its price and class in Super rather than CX or CXL trim. With its upgraded leather dash and steering wheel as well as added trim elements, the Super provides a feel that is in concert with its luxury aspirations. CX and CXL trims, while of sufficient quality and build, suffer from some cheap plastic that seems out of place.

Controls and gauges are refreshingly intuitive, simple and well-placed, especially considering the trend in recent years of shoehorning as much technology as possible into luxury cars at the usual expense of actual function. Comfort and room in the front are ample, and the seats have the right mixture of support and comfort for long-distance travel. In the rear, the Lucerne is touted as fitting three abreast, but with a slight lack of foot space, an uneven floor and seat cushion, this isn't quite realistic. Some taller riders might have issues, but otherwise adults will find plenty of space.

Of particular note is Buick’s QuietTuning, an engineering initiative with the goal of reducing wind, road, and powertrain noise throughout the build process. This includes a stiffened body structure, mirrors and windshield wipers designed to reduce wind turbulence, and an acoustically tuned engine cover and pistons coated with a special polymer to quiet the powertrain.

Safety

2009 Buick Lucerne

Standard safety features include dual front, front side, and curtain side airbags, antilock four-wheel disc brakes, a tire-pressure monitor and daytime running lights. Supers additionally benefit from brake assist, anti-skid, and a rear obstacle detection system, although these are available as options on the CX and CXL.

NHTSA ratings showed top scores of five stars for all categories except side impacts, which received four stars.

What Owners Think

Owners find that for the price, the base CX trim offers far too little value and performance. A well-equipped CXL seems to come closer to the mark, but the improved suspension, steering, and increased power of the Super are really needed to fulfill the model's aspirations. Its long list of options has also garnered praise.

Updated

A CarGurus contributor since 2008, Michael started his career writing about cars with the SCCA - winning awards during his time as editor of Top End magazine. Since then, his journalistic travels have taken him from NY to Boston to CA, completing a cross-country tour on a restored vintage Suzuki. While his preference is for fine German automobiles - and the extra leg room they so often afford - his first automobile memories center around impromptu Mustang vs. Corvette races down the local highway, in the backseat of his father's latest acquisition.

What's your take on the 2009 Buick Lucerne?

People researching a 2009 Buick Lucerne contacted a dealer about

2009 Buick Lucerne, Front Quarter View, exterior, manufacturer
Buick Lucerne
33% of the time
Buick LaCrosse
12% of the time
Ford Taurus
5% of the time
Lucerne
Looking for a Used Lucerne in your area?
CarGurus has 3,999 nationwide Lucerne listings starting at $2,987.
ZIP:

Buick Lucerne Questions

donjake
0

Location Of Airconditioner Draintube

4 views with no answers yet
MAXPLACE
0

Passenger Floor Is Getting Wet, Where Is The Water Coming From?, It Doesn't...

282 views with 3 answers (last answer 2 months ago)
chlngr6
0

The Remote And Inside Button Do Not Open Trunk. Fuse Is Ok. Is Therer A Man...

418 views with 1 answer (last answer about a year ago)
Richard04
0

Differences For Cxl-1, Cxl-2, Cxl-3, Cxl-4, Cxl-5?

Buick lists 5 version of 2009 Lucerne CXL. What are differences for CXL-1, CXL-2, CXL-3, CXL-4, CXL-5?

233 views with 2 answers (last answer 2 years ago)
Butch43
0

What Is Definition Of "instant Market Value"? Is It Just Some Marketing Ter...

Am looking for a new "used" car.

125 views with 1 answer (last answer 2 years ago)